NC Supreme Court Rules Courts Cannot Decide on Gerrymandering Claims, Reverses Anti-Voter ID Ruling

NC Supreme Court Rules Courts Cannot Decide on Gerrymandering Claims, Reverses Anti-Voter ID Ruling

by Nick Gilbertson

The North Carolina Supreme Court on Friday ruled that there is no legal mechanism to judge claims of “partisan gerrymandering,” giving the Republican-controlled state legislatures the ultimate authority to draw congressional maps without court intervention. In a separate case, the court reversed a decision that previously tossed out a voter identification law.

“There is no judicially manageable standard by which to adjudicate partisan gerrymandering claims,” the court concluded in a 5-2 decision of the Harper v. Hall case. “Courts are not intended to meddle in policy matters.”

The 218-page decision comes months after the court threw out legislative maps drawn by the Republican-led chambers of Congress in the Tar Heel State.

In December — after voters flipped the court red in the midterm elections giving Republicans a 5-2 majority — the outgoing Democrat-controlled Supreme Court blocked the maps and ordered the legislative bodies to create new ones, the Associated Press noted at the time. Read the rest at breitbart.com.

1 comment
  • Apparently, Nick Gilbertson (article’s author) is trying to say what the summary bug says more clearly. That is: NC Supreme Court Reinstates Voter ID.